oD forums to restructure and move
Please read and comment on this thread if you want to influence the future of the forums
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENToD forums to restructure and move Please read and comment on this thread if you want to influence the future of the forums Email & RSSSign up to oD's editorial summaries email:
NavigationThe World
ColumnsPaul Rogers Li Datong Fred Halliday Mary Kaldor Daniele Archibugi Our Authors around the Web
|
![]() |
Truth in Gaza: Palestinian victim blames Hamas for warTruth in Gaza: Palestinian
but can u quote many people whom they blame israel, that girl is telling what is dectated to her, yes some even abbas said that , but he is totally wrong. now they can let palestinians people split and it happend everywhere, it doesnt mean that this girl what she is said right, how she knows the sequences. many are decived, but for short time, and iam sure the same girl later will know the truth. the truth is clear and by the way even in gulf states and in dubai sheikh of duba cancell most of cilibrations in new year and also most singers cancell all their vestifals as a brotherhood to their people in Gaza. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
i will read later, but who is that man who wrote false things, yes we have to defend, and we now all pray against them and inshallh god will revenge for us. so what ? Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
most arabs and muslims now sympathize with hamas, and dont like her to resender. they want her to fight for their dignity and land. it is normal and legitemate. but we asked God to be with them (ameen). they are the victom group and israel is the state of terror as it is established from first on our blood and did so many masacres as deer yaseen and now in Gaza. i blame also some of arabs as they were with them, they forget that jews in history even killed their prophets, they kill 70 prophets in one day, and also as bible said killed jesus(pbuh) which we muslims know he was raised to God and not killed or crusified. so they have a terror history and what now is doing is the continuity of their blodd to all humanbeings. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
see mike and all, iam whom always was neutral and dont like anyone to be killed, after i saw those increadible my innocnet people to die, so i pray to God as they also will taste the death as we saw it. also i pray for their kids to taste the bitter as our parents taste. so what is new? they start to kill us, so we have to react and the whole blame is the one who start and God knows that and he will sooner or later punish them and yes let them taste the same as they let us taste on, so dont try to show the people of israel now innocnet, now they are encouraging and electing the most government which kill more of our kids, so of course we will pray to God to let them also killed as they are targiting us innocent hamas and all their relatives and kids and in quran it is like that just. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
human rights activits is a big lier now to all of us. we never beleive them. no human rights given and it is given only to the aggressors. that lesson we learn it now from them. they are lyers and cant do anything to help our people innocent in Gaza whom daily are killed from the most brutal soldiers in this world. it is a war for evil as they are even more devil than the evil. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
that girl knows and all knows that rockets which kill her family is rockets made in US and the hands of cruel soldiers israeli killed her family even they have families at home. it is clear unless the world is crazy and he has no mind . really strange to speak like that. never i know that some people lye to theri selves untill they believe that they are not lyers. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"that girl knows and all knows that rockets which kill her family is rockets made in US and the hands of cruel soldiers israeli killed her family even they have families at home. it is clear unless the world is crazy and he has no mind . really strange to speak like that." That girl knows that Hamas rockets supplied by Iran were fired by Hamas from her family's home resulting in Israeli retaliation that killed her family. In a moment of anguish when the only issue to a little girl is the loss of her family, she spoke truth devoid of politics. If Hamas had not fired rockets from her home, her family would still be alive. If Hamas boasts that they use human shields, you think the video is faked? If a girl loses her family and cries out against Hamas, she is coerced? If Abbas says Hamas should stop the rockets, he is wrong? Seems to me the only one lying to themselves is you. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
and the girl knows also that hamas rockets those in retilation for the blockage of gaza and for prisoning all popoulations of palestinie in gaza and retilation for no food, no electricity, for demolishing homes, it is also a revenge from israel. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
So you are saying that despite knowing ALL this, she still holds Hamas responsible for the death of her family! Thanks for clearling that up. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
i dont search much in net . but u can go to aljazeera and read all posts even bbc in arabic, they did many pollos and all of them blame israel of that. the majority of muslims and arabs blame israel and u dont read news and how many demonstrations all blame israel. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
first i went to the video and was not availiable, i didnt see the vido, but even if it there, u dont know that still there are a media which can enforce or dictate things to her to say. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Couldn't find the link to the victim's statement? Try this one. It worked fine for me. It's in arabic with English subtitles. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLIdxF-GHWw Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
i didnt say she admit the blame on hamas, i told u what i know and i dont know how u manipulate my sayings as usual. No, it is you who
No, it is you who manipulated HER sayings. She is a child mourning the loss of her family, not motivated by politics. It is in the depths of her pain that she speaks the truth that you would like to deny. That without Hamas, her family would still be alive. I can understand why you do not want to face that fact. It is devastating to admit your complicity with Hamas resulted in innocent deaths. But while truth is not easy, it is still the truth. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
the truth is to end this terrible occupation of palestine, and let us free like the whole people in the content. all what is happening is revenge and that girl dont know the whole story, still i didnt see the video but i will , now old people are dont know the truth, so how come u want this poor girl to know . really it is amazing, eventhough if one said like that, but majority tell the opposite, so who u will choose? go to pulls and u will know the real truth even if u dont like it. it is truth and we are in the side of truth and u and u country in the path of wrong and u have to accept it. at least our conscious is clean and clear when we will die. at least our hands is not full of blood of innocent people, at least we didnt steal another country to live in. u know the rest of the story. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
did u read comments on that girl ? all are against and blame israel,and also as i know the channel of al quds is with hamas or alagsa , so i think it is from fath as even i didnt hear the voice of the announcer what he is asking the girl at the end. but u can read all comments on that video to know the real truth mr mike. Clearly this is from Fatah,
Clearly this is from Fatah, which seeks to discredit Hamas...not a difficult task. What I read were the English subtitles in which she blamed Hamas for the war that killed her parents. What are you reading? Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
you didnt answer about the demonstrations aroung the world blaming israel and not hams. are u a normal person?u cant see or read, go and read what links and i told u to see demonstrations and majority are against israel and blame them and only u and owly say the reverse Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Abdulksaida, You do write a lot of old rubbish. Hamas began firing rockets into Israel. Under International Law (of which so many are so fond on here) that is a crime and Israel does have a right to respond to such an 'aggressive act'. As a Palestinian and someone who supports Hamas and its actions you have no right to complain at the actions of Israel. If you don't want innocent Palestinians killed then tell Hamas to stop firing their bloody rockets. Now do you understand ?? Oh and by the way. I am no fan or admirer of Israel. I am by nature and inclination an Arabist. As I have said before my family were friends of the Iraqi Royal Family (T.E. Lawrence etc), so ask yourself a very simple question. Why have you managed to alienate someone who should be one of your natural supporters ?? Also I had a feeling you were a medical Doctor. If this is the case (please correct me if I am wrong) I am most surprised by your rather bloody thirsty posts. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"...you didnt answer about the demonstrations aroung the world blaming israel and not hams." What is there to answer? A few demonstrations does not reflect world opinion. All that proves is there are no shortage of terrorist sympathizers for a demonstration. Fortunately for me, I do not believe in your Allah and the God I worship does not tolerate terrorism in His name. I believe Arafat is doing his happy dance in hell, along with the recent Hamas arrivals. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
All true Iron Mike. And Arafat was a disaster for the Palastinian people. And I am afraid to say that watching Hamas and Hezbollah at work I am glad everyday that I am a Christian and not a Moslem. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
iam proud to be a muslim , thanks God he chooses us to be muslims and go to paradize. inshallh all now of martyees are at paradize and just now i finish from a speech by nasrallah about day of judjment and how people will be punished or rewarded according to theri acts in life and also how groups also will be punished and that day which we will send to paradize or hell and inshallh criminals will go their to hell and those of hamas in paradize and u r not God to decide who will be their. be humble or u will cry blood at the day of judjment as u encourage the killing of innocent people by supporting the act of israel and not defendint the innocent people i was very frustrated from
i was very frustrated from the gaza, but now i hear nasrallah in manar and about that day of judjment and i become calm as iam sure god will help us and reward those people in paradize. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
u and mike are thirsty of blood as u wishes for us a nice war. it seems u relegion now christianity encourage such aggression. yes like Bush who said crucify. it seems the pure old christianity changed to blood shedding as of course u change it by having 4 books different of bible. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
we have mike in our relegious books, that before one muslim man say about someone who dont think he will enter paradize and say that , as he thinks that man will never enter paradize. so God ( allah ) siad , who is that man who decide than me, tell him that i forgive for that man his sins and he will enter paradize and the other will enter hell as he said like that. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
I posted a piece a couple of days ago (God knows where as I can't find it !!) which gave a different perspective on Hamas. In the interests of balance here is something quite different. http://www.spectator.co.uk/melaniephillips/3194846/groundhog-day-for-the-fifth-column-of-malice.thtml Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Well you could hardly have picked anyone more committed than Melanie Phillips. Besides being one of the more right wing contributors to the Daily Mail, one of the most right wing newspapers in the UK. Although being jewish does not disqualify her from having a balanced view I would suppose it further colours her views on this subject. She started out on the liberal left and has gradually drifted right as the years have passed. I expect, Owly, you will say she has learned the errors of her former ways whilst I will say it is the brain cells dying :-) She is too intelligent to not know that a call for a ceasefire would be expected to apply to Hamas too. Or to ignore the blockade which has been going on for weeks, only to be partially relieved as a gesture aimed at western journalists rather than to actually help the shortages in Gaza. It is interesting that she feels that all the western media are pro Hamas, but then short of the journalists bombing Gaza themselves, she probably would think this from her perspective. I have argued that collateral damage that is known and statisically predictable is no better than a terrorist bomb. If this were not so then it would be legitimate to drop an H-bomb on a country, take out a whole city, but then claim that it was actually targetted at a government building. I exaggerate here to make a point of principle because the Israelis do take care to avoid civilian casualties, but then they do know that any response will be disproportionate and that there will be a high number of civilian casualties. Several eyes and teeth for an eye is the new ethic it seems. As for the arguments of storing weapons and materials away from civilian areas, it should be noted that Gaza is not a large area and is very densely populated. Moreover, from a military perspective in such an asymmetric war, to contruct sites for weapons storage would be tantamount to putting a bullseye on them, especially given the quality of Israel's intelligence service. She quotes that many more died in Germany and Japan than in Britain or America, therefore it is somehow hypocritical to suggest that there should be equality of numbers when one side are clearly the bad guys. She conveniently does not mention the 20 million Russian casualties though. Perhaps because they were not really good guys either (commies you know). Every British news that I have seen has "balanced" the carnage in Gaza with the suffering of Israelis watching a rocket land in a distant farm field and spent some time covering the funeral of the people who were unlucky enough to be killed by a rocket. She says that this did not happen, but in my extensive viewing this is patently not true. Even those commie bast**ds at the BBC showed the Israeli perpective. Even Al Jazeera does! If you were to weight the coverage proprtionately to the deaths occurring then Israel would not get any significant coverage at all. There is more to show in Gaza but embarrassingly little to show on the ISraeli side. But then Ms Philips usually makes me angry so I should expect this sort of rhetoric. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Now Englishman, don't be so bigoted and closed mind. Just because a view and an opinion comes from the right does not make it wrong. This seems to be a default position round here but I credited you with slightly more intelligence; seems one was wrong ! And does the fact Philips is Jewish having a bearing on the validity of what she has written, or are you merely being anti-Semitic ? It is a valid question before you huff and puff. 'Ms Philips makes me angry' and that is because she contradicts what you believe everyone should believe, and you can't properly argue with what she writes. I will ignore much of your 'rant' as being unworthy of you. However as to the media how do you know it is being 'balanced' ? I think it is more skewed towards the Palestinians myself. The footage and the way the reports are presented shows that, as does the way rocket attacks on Israel are reported. A lot of it is subtle and it probably passes you by. As Melanie Philips is not to your taste you might try this instead -: Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Ha ha! I have just looked up Melanie on Wikipedia so I suppose this may not be true, but it says she has referred to Barak Obama as a "revolutionary Marxist" and has called the Archbisop of Canterbury Anti-semitic, saying the catholic and Anglican churches in the UK are paving the way to a second holocaust. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
It is not because it is from the right wing that it makes it wrong, it is just because it is wrong. I hope that my rant came over with a degree of humour as, I find her views so off the wall that I cannot take her very seriously. But some thought Stalin amusing at times too :-) You know my views on the effects of tribalism and, although I have jewish friends who do not support Israel's government actions, there are those that certainly do and, possibly worse, there are those who I know would not agree but cannot bring themselves to say so. So yes, I think that the fact that she is jewish does affect what she says and how she thinks, though it would be better if it did not. As I said, this does not disqualify her from having an opinion, but may explain why she may not be viewing the situation wholly dispassionately and without bias. I disagree with what she believes and think I made a case against what she said. David Aaronovitch is more of my political hew which I suppose is why you gave the URL for his article. And, as you might expect, I agree with most of what he says. I think the answer to one of his points, about why we rail at Israel but not so much at specific violent acts elsewhere, is that we expect more from a country that is, in many ways like our own. I also think we do complain about acts of violence, like the stoning to death of young girls or the funding of suicide missions. What planet has David been on if he does not see the (over)reaction to suicide bomb threats. But what reaction would there have been in Britain if the British forces had attacked Eire for harbouring IRA terrorists, because they did so and had a good deal of support from the local populace. It may have taken 40 years, and maybe it is not wholly settled, but it is in a whole lot better state than Israel-Palestine situation. I know it is not the same, but there are many parallels in the way Sinn Fein argued with the Ballot box whilst having various unofficial IRA groups with armalites. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
englishman Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
also now palestinians family going from home to home to hide, they told them they will explode this home beside them, so they went to other relative to stay, and then also they got another alarm , so they are refugee now in gaza also, from home to home Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Abdulksaida, Mashal has offered a 10 year ceasefire (hudna) in exchange for a return to 1967 borders, right of return of all Palestinian refugees and control of East Jerusalem. This was not acceptable to Israel who believe that if they give way to this, but without any permanent agreement, there would still be factions of Palestinians who would continue a war to try to eliminate the state of Israel, but that then Israel would be in a much less military secure position. As I said before, one of the problems is that Hamas's constitution demands the dismantling of the state of Israel, and Mashal reinforces that view. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
I suggest you read the article in today's Daily Telegraph. Perhaps more graphically than most it shows why the Palestinians are fools lead by idiots. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/barackobama/4077213/Even-Obama-cant-solve-the-Middle-East-problem---and-hed-be-foolish-to-try.html Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Well, I don't hold with your conclusion, but the article is a very good one and summarises the situation quite well. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
owly Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
it seems israel wants today to enter gaza by road, now no electricity in Gaza and any one who has an atom of blood to watch aljazeera and see kids on grounds of hospital died and doctors cant do anything. till now they destroy 11 mosques of worshipping and we see alive photos. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Abdulksaida, Did you read the article in today's Daily Telegraph ? One doubts it. Pity really because you would have learnt that the West (President Clinton) tried very hard to bring peace to the Middle East, but Arafat would not agree. He could have had almost everything he wanted and yet he could not agree. Arafat was an idiot, a liar, a thief and (in all probability) a murderer. He lead the Palestinian people nowhere. And I'm sorry to say I do not believe that you have any interest in making peace with Israel. It is all hate, hate and yet more hate, added to the delight in being a victim. Iron Mike has made a very valid point in his posts. Hamas fired rockets into Israel, so you have no right to complain when Israel strikes back. If you were a good Muslim you would condemn what Hamas has done, but you don't and wont because it suits your purposes for there to be war and suffering. You are lucky, living in Kuwait and being freed by Western force of Arms from the tyranny of Saddam Hussain. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
owly Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
now as they start ground attack they killed 5 with kids. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
arafat cant give israeli what they want. i used to hate yasser arafat as he always negotiate with them and dont forget that PLO is the first which recognize israel. so we hate yasser arafat as he recognize them and see what they did to him after that act which all muslims consider as a shame, then we say we will wait , may be we will get our rights. but what was the rules all not good. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
owly when israel did genin masacre did hamas launch any rockets. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
can u tell me owly what clinton propose to arafat to accept? Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Read the article the link for which I posted. It is explained in the text of the article. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Pasting the link for this article which some might find interesting just to annoy Englishman ! Enjoy. http://www.spectator.co.uk/melaniephillips/3206066/the-real-agenda.thtml Some solid polling that
Some solid polling that supports US solidarity with Israel in the current conflict. Poll: 12-31-08 http://www.rasmussenreports.com Fifty-five percent (55%) of adults, however, believe the Palestinians are to blame for the current situation in Gaza, while 13% point the finger at the Israelis. Nearly one-third (32%) aren’t sure. Men are far more sympathetic to the Israelis than women. Fifty-six percent (56%) of men support Israel’s military action, compared to 34% of women. Sixty-two percent (62%) of men say the Palestinians are to blame versus 48% of women. Sixty-seven percent (67%) of those who say they are following news out of Gaza Very Closely support Israel's military action, while 30% favor diplomacy. Seventy-three percent (73%) of Republicans blame the Palestinians, as opposed to 47% of Democrats. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
u know most US citizens are jewish and they support the aggresision of israel and its establishment, so of course they will support them. US is the most country who give israel sophisticated weapons to live and try to make it legal inspite of the truth that she is illegitamte country. it is the illegitemate baby from not even marriage between israel and US . it is not astonishing this things. some they dont know the truth which are not jewish from the criminal media who is bias and dont tell the whole story and that is israel is the aggressor country who steal land of others. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
always us support israel , so it is not new . especially hamas are muslims and try to apply sharia and of course by bias media they show them as the same as al qaeda and terror organisation and sorry to say most americans lay persons are ingnorant and not educated and interisting about others in the world as i told u. all the blame is on u western media and islamphobia only. "u know most US citizens are
"u know most US citizens are jewish and they support the aggresision of israel and its establishment, so of course they will support them." "...and as i know american people have not much knowledge of others cultures and history, they care only about money and sorry to say sex. that the normal people of them care of and less care about issues more important and logic and those people are with the truth as with palestinians." I think you are displaying an apalling ignorance of the US, it's culture and its people if this represents what you believe about us. Jews are a small minority of the demographics of the US...not nearly the influence you give them credit. The US people are one of the most generous in the world and also one of the most pragmatic. They understand that Palestinians have a choice between terrorism and negotiation. When you choose terror, our support declines. If you want change that, then depose Hamas and live in peace with your neighbors. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
mike and owly read this article from OD on gaza http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/article5420584.ece really it described well the situation. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
abdulksaida, I read the piece from The Times, the link for which you kindly posted. I believe I actually posted a link to this article myself, but I forget on which thread I did this. But thank you for posting the link. I wish you were not as anti-Western and anti-Christian as you seem to be. Many of us are concerned at what is happening in Gaza, but we also understand that the Palestinians are not blameless in this matter. If I were you I would seriously reconsider my support for Hamas. If they had the true interests of the people of Gaza to heart they would have concentrated on improving the lives of their people like enlightened rulers rather than launching a War. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
i think u dont know u society also mike the one who have much money , usually have the influence on others. most arabs and muslims thinks that jewish are the one who control US or at least propagate false news and they have most media and now our struggle is going on by media. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
owly since there election , borders of Gaza closed, put them in seize, now israeli enter to palestinians TV and propagte false things about hamas and threaten palestinians to be with hamas. now womens from all over the world calling lay palestinians in their homes and talk to them and try to know information from them about hamas to kill them later. do u think we have to go to UN? we went, so what she did? they didnt implement any force to israel to let them accept or apply any resolution because of the support of US do u think we will go to criminal court? we went, what happend, nothing so that is our last resort , no other one after that long suffer. do u agree? Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
The more you speak about Americans with authority, the more you reveal your ignorance. You can offer an opinion about what Americans believe (or don't believe) but share no evidence supporting your opinion. It suprises me that you have any dealings in science since that requires empirical evidence, not speculation. What evidence do you have of American opinions or what they believe? How about some evidence to support your belief in the level of influence of the "Jewish Lobby?" I provided statistical polling data of American opinions on the current conflict, including the fact the majority of Americans (including me) believe Palestine and Israel can live in peace. We are also more objective in our understanding that lasting peace comes from peaceful negotiation, not 6,000 rockets. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"do u think we have to complain to US? what she did, she support the aggressor more. do u think we have to go to UN? we went, so what she did? they didnt implement any force to israel to let them accept or apply any resolution because of the support of US do u think we will go to criminal court? we went, what happend, nothing" Nothing is done because you don't have a case! Please explain why Arafat rejected the Oslo accords which offered a REAL roadmap for peace? You've had multiple chances for real peace and have rejected them all because for you, it is all or nothing. Either Israel goes, or no peace. Sorry, but the world has spoken and they said, "That's not acceptable." So you can sulk and wonder why no one comes to your aid and enjoy the situation your beloved Hamas has created. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
Uh, Mike, The Oslo accords failed mostly because of Israeli bad faith in negotiating time-tables for withdrawal. It was certainly not "all or nothing" by anyone's account. You seem to be attributing things to Arafat (PLO / PA) that may be true of the fringe groups and Hamas, but are just not true as you are stating them. And... Every civilized country is now coming to the aid of the Palestinians (even Britain!), only the US under the barbarism of GWB will not react humanely. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
mike you wrote "We are also more objective in our understanding that lasting peace comes from peaceful negotiation, not 6,000 rockets." so also we are more realistic and objectives and we dont now belive after killing 560 innocent palestinians and 2290 injured will establish these 2 peacful countries. so 6000 rockets if they rocketed to palestinians and didnt kill only 4 peple so may be peace will come. i dont know how u think, and you think u r right. now more and more hate is created already from the aggresson of israel, and i dont think it will quickly healed. by longing the occupation which israel can withdwaw and only implement UN resolution so 2 states can come. I told the whole world and i swear that israel is also afraid of 2 peacful states. all of us arabs and muslims knows that. still the west is beliving israel, but one day they will be shocked more and more from the terror act of that stolen country. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
mike, if the most imortant thing is media . tell me from normal american would get information about palestine and the aggression of israel. it is from media in America, so whom control the media there? they are jewish whom support israel with no limits. americans lay persons dont know the whole story from begiining becasue of the criminal media which jewish are holding it. so even by scientific thinking we will get to that conclusion also. unless u in america have not biased media , so i think the poll will reverse to the side of innocent palestinians and liberate palestine. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
This is a different perspective. The article was flagged by OD. Here is the link -: http://www.independent.ie/lifestyle/why-the-israeli-people-have-finally-had-enough-1592022.html Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
I've never read a more biased opinion piece as Owly posted from Ian O'Doherty. Let's just look at the use of adjectives as grounds for dismissal of that piece of tripe, shall we? "Footage of air strikes with the ensuing photogenic explosions and dramatic plumes of smoke, quickly followed by clips of collapsed buildings and enraged mourners, makes far better copy than actually looking at the reasons why Israel has done what it's done." Well Ian, to be sure, the reasons why Israel would blow up civilian ghettos is sure to get lost in the humanitarian disaster those bombs create. The Israelis are stupid if they did not calculate that outcome. "The problem with that conclusion -- and it's not something you're going to learn from the BBC and most other outlets -- is that, contrary to the currently popular belief, Israel is actually acting with a ridiculous degree of restraint." Ian, your fucking insane man. There is nothing "ridiculous" about Israeli restraint here, nothing. But do continue... "I know many people in the southern Israeli town of Sderot and what is remarkable about their stories is not the number or make of rockets which have fallen on them on a daily basis for years, but the psychological carnage this wreaked upon them. Carnage eh? Really? There are many adjectives that would be appropriate here... trauma, damage, and so forth, but "carnage" is simply not appropriate. Drawing an equivalence between the difficulties of life in Sderot - and let's be clear, these residents can actually LEAVE if it's that bad, unlike the Gazans - to actual carnage of blown up families is outrageous and callous. Fuck you Ian. "One woman freely admitted to me that she hasn't had a proper night's sleep in more than two years..." Take a vacation lady, go to the dead sea to a spa. Utter Bullshit. "And, over the last week, we have seen carefully manipulated footage of dead civilians, with the fact that they were effectively used as human shields conveniently ignored." This canard has gone on long enough. The facts are that civilians are being killed as collateral damage and Ian would have us believe that Hamas fighters are throwing them into the line of fire with absolutely no evidence of it except the bald assertion that this is the case. "When Israel pulled out of Gaza -- ironically, the last battalion of IDF troops to leave Gaza contained some people from Sderot -- they were acceding to international and internal pressure." Yes, but they effectively contained all access to it by land sea or air, so how exactly is that leaving? They did not leave, they redeployed to more effectively strangle the life out of it. You are truly a fool Ian, and certainly you are no journalist when you can't get history right as you then demonstrate: "And, lo and behold, virtually as soon as the last jeep left Gaza the rockets started. And then the blockade began, and the whole damn mess started all over again." ??? When, exactly, was their no blockade of Gaza? Who was firing rockets? Let's see some evidence of this time-line you merely assert. "Israel is the front line of the war between democracy and Islamic fascism." Or, alternatively, they are the inspiration for Islamic facism's rise in the world. Chicken or the egg. But this is what actually got me angry here: "Would you rather live in a society with a free press" The press is not currently free in Israel. "equal rights for women -- and anyone who knows an Israeli woman will know that they're not easily suppressed" Religious zealots in Israel have buses where woman must ride in the back, that is not equal. "equal rights for gay people" "and a proud and stubborn belief in the right of the individual to lead their life in the way that they see fit" See previous link "or would you rather exist in a society where women who dare to speak their mind are executed, where gay people are not just shunned but murdered and where having a dissenting thought marks you out for death?" Damn, sounds like both societies are the embodiment of hellish religiosity. I would choose neither, and I would condemn both. Please stop making specious claims that North American and European societies share "values" with Israel. My values don't include collective punishment of entire populations because I don't like their politics. "But in a sick and twisted irony, they are mourned more by Israelis than by Hamas, who know that every dead Palestinian kid is worth another piece of propaganda." What is sick and twisted Ian, is that I think you believe what you say there. Bravo, you have descended another notch on the rhetorical ladder: Dead arab kid = bad news cycle for Israel You are a sick bastard "Here in the West, where we share the same values as Israel, we need to start standing shoulder with this tiny oasis of democracy in a vast desert of savagery." No, in fact we don't, and as you will see, we won't. Here in the West, we need to condemn the cycle of violence and savagery on BOTH sides as these are values that we cannot endorse by anyone, anywhere, democratic or not (what democracy has to do with is not clear) Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"Here in the West, we need to condemn the cycle of violence and savagery on BOTH sides as these are values that we cannot endorse by anyone, anywhere, democratic or not (what democracy has to do with is not clear)." Now who's being disingenuous? Condemn both sides? That hasn't happened, has it? All resolutions so far have no mention of culpability by Hamas. This is a major sticking point that prevents any cease-fire. You diminish the psychological effect of living under constant stress of air-raid sirens that give less than 30 seconds to find what cover is possible and wait to see if you will survive. That's pretty heartless from a feelings-based Liberal, isn't it? I wonder if you would be so cavalier if YOUR family faced 6,000 rockets from your neighbor to the south? Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"You diminish the psychological effect of living under constant stress" And you diminish the stress of living under siege. You are even so callous as to blame the besieged for the siege. 30 seconds is quite a few more than Gazans receive at the end of a tank muzzle Mike. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
"And you diminish the stress of living under siege. You are even so callous as to blame the besieged for the siege. " When the besiged bring the seige on themselves, you damn right I blame them! That's not being callous; that's being truthful. That's justice. Sometimes the truth hurts...like sympathy fixes nothing. Pragmatism does. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
When pragmatism leads to unwarranted death tolls, a futile strategy and criminal collective punishment, it's no longer pragmatic. It's reprehensible. Unlike your black and white version of events, I view things with many shades of gray. To be certain, the Israelis have crossed some lines in the sand that make them no better than Hamas. The only difference is that Israels goals are not attainable which I believe they know, raising some important questions about their motives. That the Israeli election is looming large and that the actors in this violence have a stake in portraying themselves as strong nationalists is no small part of them pursuing such a failed policy. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
mike if palestinians were rocketed by 6000 miscles from israel , and if they only kill 4 people, so they will celebrate and be happy and dance may be on streets, that they know the miscels in not effective and that is. i swear the war is not becasue of those miscels, it is used as a dirty execuse to launch a hullocust and murder to kill innocent palestinaisn and first of all to win elections for dirty israeli leaders. so it is for only dirty elections which inshallh they will not get it proberly and damn to them and their elction if that is their democracy by killing innocent palestinians. Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
...first of all to win elections for dirty israeli leaders. That part, abdulksaida, is certainly true and accurate. Livni and Barrak have taken a gamble that they believe will take the initiative away from Netanyahu in the electoral race. A very cynical move given they are probably aware that there is a very low probability of achieving their goals. They just want to be perceived as "strong". Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
mike why u dont answer me ? did they give him that or now we are no longer palestinians to ask for our homeland and homeland of our grandfathers and grandmothers and for many generations we lived there before u or others jews from all over the world come and steal our own country can u tell me, did clinton agree that refugee can return back or not? never u tell me what they give arafat to accept. nothing Truth in Gaza: Palestinian
the truth is till now humaniterian crises deepening and israle refused to cease fire. humanitarian authority said that war in gaza has majority killed which are children and mowen. do u thik God will not revenge for those innocent kids to be killed. many times i said if israel dont feel peace as the idiot bush said despite america the only strong country in the world wich support israel , and they are afraid from hamas, so how peace will come to them. they are fully supported from USA from 60 years and till now few palestinians with no weapons let them afraid, so i think all weapons of the world will not make a state of israel any more safe. Me thinks things are going
Me thinks things are going to get s little more heated, news agencies are reporting that the Israelis just struck a UN school in Gaza killing at least 40 people. Even Drudge has it running on its banner, apparently the visual carnage is extreme. I wonder if Mike and Owly will continue being so cavalier about the innocent being killed. |
![]() |
openUSA Latest |
Finally...some truth in the current conflict.
A Palestinian girl whose family members were killed yesterday in Gaza:
"I say Hamas is the cause of all wars."
by Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook, Dec. 29, 2008
A Palestinian girl whose family members was killed yesterday in Gaza after an Israeli air attack was interviewed today on Palestinian TV and placed the blame for the war on Hamas:
[Girl] "We were sleeping 7 girls in the room. We were asleep and didn't know what was happening. In the morning all the bricks were on top of my head, and the heads of all my sisters. My 4 year old sister next to me was dead."
[Interviewer] "How many were you?"
[Girl] "Seven.In the other room were my mother, my father, my yonger brother and another sister, who is 13 days old. I say, Hamas is the cause, in the first place, of all wars."
[PATV (Fatah) Dec. 29, 2008]
http://www.pmw.org.il/Bulletins_Dec2008.htm#b2912082
Boring and enraging Liberals with the truth since 2004